#150 - Cheating On The Budget
Fiscal Smoke
Governments can employ various strategies to give the appearance of spending less while actually increasing expenditures. These tactics often involve creative accounting, strategic communication, and reallocating costs. Here are some common methods:
1. Reclassifying Expenditures
Shift Spending Categories: Move certain expenditures from the regular budget to "off-budget" accounts, such as special funds or trusts, making it appear as though the official budget is smaller.
Example: Military spending reclassified as "emergency funding" or "contingency operations."
Capital vs. Current Expenditures: Classify investments as capital expenditures rather than operational costs, as capital costs might be spread over many years.
2. Deficit Spending and Debt
Borrowing Instead of Budgeting: Fund programs or initiatives through borrowing rather than including them in the current budget. While this doesn’t reduce spending, it obscures immediate costs.
Example: Infrastructure projects financed through bonds rather than direct allocation.
Interest Deferral: Delay interest payments on debt or restructure loans to push costs into the future.
3. Hidden or Delayed Costs
Unfunded Mandates: Shift costs to state or local governments by creating new requirements without providing funding, reducing federal spending on paper.
Example: Federal healthcare or education reforms that state governments must implement.
Deferred Maintenance: Postpone necessary upkeep for infrastructure, buildings, or equipment, reducing short-term spending but increasing future costs.
Phase-Ins: Introduce programs with delayed implementation dates to push costs into future budgets.
Example: Tax cuts or new social programs that start years after being passed.
4. Inflationary Adjustments
Nominal Spending Freeze: Freeze nominal spending while allowing inflation to erode the real value of expenditures, creating the appearance of spending less without adjusting for reduced purchasing power.
Overly Optimistic Projections: Assume higher-than-realistic inflation or economic growth rates to make spending appear smaller relative to GDP.
5. Use of Private Sector or Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs)
Privatization: Shift government functions to private companies, reducing visible public spending while still incurring costs indirectly through subsidies, guarantees, or long-term contracts.
Example: Contracting private companies for prisons, roads, or healthcare services.
Leasing Assets: Lease government-owned assets to private entities for a short-term cash influx while sacrificing long-term revenue.
6. Tax Expenditures and Credits
Tax Breaks Over Direct Spending: Use tax credits, deductions, or exemptions to achieve policy goals instead of direct spending. These are less visible in the budget but still reduce government revenue.
Example: Subsidizing industries through tax incentives rather than outright grants.
7. Accounting Tricks
Baseline Budgeting: Define "cuts" as reductions to future planned increases, rather than actual decreases in spending.
Example: A planned 10% budget increase reduced to 5% is framed as a "cut."
Fund Transfers: Move money between different programs or accounts to create the illusion of savings in one area while spending it elsewhere.
Creative Reporting: Use one-time revenues (e.g., selling public land or assets) to offset annual expenditures, creating the appearance of fiscal discipline.
8. Public Relations and Framing
Selective Highlighting: Emphasize reductions in specific programs or departments to draw attention away from overall spending increases.
Example: Highlighting cuts to "wasteful" spending while increasing funding for politically favorable programs.
Program Consolidation: Combine multiple programs under one umbrella, making it appear as though spending is reduced when total funding remains the same or increases.
9. Leveraging Future Generations
Pension Liabilities: Underfund public pensions, reducing current obligations while increasing future liabilities.
Social Security and Medicare Accounting: Use optimistic assumptions about future funding to justify current spending increases.
10. Emergency or Temporary Spending
Crisis Spending: Declare certain expenditures as temporary responses to emergencies, even if they later become permanent.
Example: "Stimulus" packages or relief programs that are never rolled back.
Supplemental Budgets: Use supplemental or mid-year budgets to fund additional expenditures outside of the regular budget process.
By employing these methods, governments can present budgets that appear leaner than they are, while still funding initiatives that increase overall expenditures. This approach often relies on obscuring long-term liabilities, creative accounting, and strategic communication to manage public perception.
Click on any category below to see more…
